Another OT Heartbreak: Can the Maple Leafs Solve This Puzzle?

2 min read• Published January 22, 2026 at 2:13 p.m.
Featured image
Logo Crest

The Maple Leafs are no strangers to heart-stopping hockey, but the last ten games have turned overtime into a recurring lesson in frustration. Wednesday night’s 2-1 loss to Detroit was just the latest chapter: Dylan Larkin’s OT goal sealed the sweep of the season series, and the scoreboard tells only part of the story.

Toronto has played eight games that went past regulation in the last ten, and they’ve lost seven of them. That’s a tough stretch to swallow for any team, but it’s also a snapshot of just how competitive these games are. Goaltending, defensive discipline, and a single moment can make the difference between a win and a replay of a familiar heartbreak.

Head coach Craig Berube saw it as a pretty even game.

Coach Berube summed it up nicely: “Pretty even game. I thought we had a lot of chances in the first two periods, and we couldn’t get it by him. They made a pretty good push in the third. Both goalies were outstanding tonight. That’s what I saw.” On nights like this, the Leafs aren’t being outplayed — they’re being tested. Joseph Woll kept the team within reach with 39 saves, showing poise and resilience after a previous rough outing. His performance kept this one “winnable” right until the buzzer.

Yet patterns matter. The team has struggled to close out games when the clock runs out, leaving fans wondering whether it’s just the randomness of OT or a symptom of something more profound. Shots tilt, energy wanes, and tiny decision-making errors become amplified. One failed penalty shot, a late scramble goal — suddenly the outcome isn’t decided by skill alone, but by timing, composure, and perhaps a touch of luck.

What lessons are the Maple Leafs learning in overtime?

There are lessons here. Toronto is learning how to handle pressure-packed minutes at the end of tight games. The players are competitive, the systems hold up, and the effort is there. But the frustration can’t help but grow. Fixing the team’s overtime woes depends upon experience, instincts, and learning to trust each other when the ice tilts.

Another overtime loss is part of the growing pains of a team still figuring out how to finish. The puzzle isn’t unsolvable — just maddeningly persistent. And for Leafs fans, that makes every game past sixty minutes equal parts thrilling and nerve-racking.

Related: Easton Cowan's on the Steep Part of His Learning Curve