Maple Leafs Have Made Gavin McKenna's NHL Adjustment Too Hard

• 2 min read• Published November 16, 2026 at 11:52 a.m.
Featured image
Logo Crest

Something feels a little backward about how the Toronto Maple Leafs are handling Gavin McKenna. They have an 18-year-old first-overall pick with exceptional offensive instincts, terrific hands, and an ability to see plays developing before other players recognize the opportunity. Yet, as he adjusts to the NHL, he's spending more time trying to stay involved than using the offensive skills that made him such an exciting prospect.

McKenna Has Put Up Respectable Numbers.

Through 22 games, McKenna has six goals and 13 points. That's a pretty respectable introduction to the NHL, especially for someone who is barely out of his teens. But he's also averaging just 13:55 of ice time per game, playing on the third line, and has lost his spot on the first power-play unit since John Tavares returned. His recent production has slowed, and he's acknowledged that finding the puck and staying engaged can be difficult when his shifts are limited.

I don't think anyone should expect the Maple Leafs to build their entire lineup around an 18-year-old. McKenna has plenty to learn, and part of becoming a good NHL player is discovering how to contribute when the game isn't going your way. Defensive responsibilities, difficult matchups, and nights when the puck simply doesn't find you are part of the job. Those are lessons every young player has to learn. But there's a difference between teaching someone to become a complete player and taking away too much of what makes him special.

Related: Is Jim Hiller Missing Something His Maple Leafs’ Players Need?

Is There a Better Balance for McKenna?

That's where I wonder whether Toronto is getting the balance right. McKenna didn't become the first overall pick because he was particularly good at playing a quiet, checking-line role. He got there because he could create offence, make difficult passes, find open ice, and change the direction of a game with the puck on his stick. Those skills don't automatically disappear when a player reaches the NHL. They need opportunities to develop against better competition.

There's also something to be said for confidence. Young players don't necessarily develop by making every shift a lesson in what they can't do. Sometimes they need room to make mistakes, try something creative, and discover their abilities still translate at the next level. If McKenna is constantly looking for ways to stay involved, rather than being encouraged to make things happen, the adjustment becomes even harder.

The Maple Leafs Shouldn't Make McKenna Another Problem.

The Maple Leafs have enough problems without creating another one with their most promising young player. Jim Hiller has to find a way to challenge McKenna while still allowing him to play to his strengths. That doesn't mean giving him unlimited ice time or handing him a permanent spot on the top line. It means recognizing what they have and finding ways to use it.

Toronto spent its first overall pick on a player who can make offence happen. It should be careful not to coach too much of that out of him.

Related: Why Do the Maple Leafs Miss Morgan Rielly So Much?