Chayka's Biggest Gamble Is That He's Right, and Others Are Wrong
There are a lot of people looking at John Chayka's first six weeks as Maple Leafs general manager and saying he's gambling on Sergei Bobrovsky and Darren Raddysh. I don't think that's quite right. The real gamble isn't on those two players. It's on himself.
Every NHL general manager believes he can evaluate talent. They almost have to. But there's a big difference between believing you're a good evaluator and staking the future of one of hockey's biggest franchises on that belief. That's exactly what Chayka has done.
Related: What Does Moving Nicholas Robertson Say About the Maple Leafs?
Is Chayka’s defining feature his confidence?
Think about the two biggest moves he's made. With Bobrovsky, he's essentially saying that one bad season at age 37 doesn't erase everything that came before it. He believes the rest of the league is putting too much weight on a .877 save percentage and not enough on a goalie who carried Florida to three straight Stanley Cup Finals.
Then there's Darren Raddysh. Almost every NHL executive watched him spend years bouncing around the minors before finally breaking through. Chayka watched the same player and came to a very different conclusion. He didn't see a journeyman having one magical season. He saw a late bloomer who had finally figured it out.
Give Chayka credit. He isn't afraid to raise the stakes.
Those are two completely different players. But they're really the same bet. Chayka is betting that everyone else is wrong. He's betting that the market has overreacted to Bobrovsky's decline and underappreciated Raddysh's emergence. If he's right, the Maple Leafs have acquired two impact players for less than their true value.
If he's wrong, the contracts won't just look expensive. They'll define his tenure in Toronto. That's what makes this fascinating. Most general managers spread their risk around. They make lots of smaller moves and hope enough of them work out. Chayka doesn't seem interested in that approach.
If Chayka were a baseball manager, he wouldn't be playing small ball.
He has changed nearly half the roster in a matter of weeks, and his two biggest moves weren't safe ones. They were conviction moves. They say, I trust my evaluation more than I trust conventional wisdom.
Maybe that's exactly what the Maple Leafs needed. Maybe the organization had become too cautious, too worried about making mistakes. Or maybe confidence and overconfidence are separated by only one thing. Results.
We'll spend the next few years talking about whether Bobrovsky still had one more run left or whether Raddysh was worth $68 million. Those may not be the real questions. The bigger question is whether John Chayka is really a better evaluator of talent than the other 31 NHL general managers.
Because, in the end, that's the bet he's really making.