Horrible Start? The Maple Leafs Have Been Here Before

• 2 min read• Published November 19, 2026 at 8:55 a.m.
Featured image
Logo Crest

One of the Maple Leafs Facebook pages I read almost every day is Toronto Maple Leafs Central. Today, they posted a graphic asking whether this is the worst start in Maple Leafs history. Interestingly, at some point in every disappointing season, at least some Maple Leafs fans start looking backward. Usually, it's to remember better days. This time, however, the history being revisited isn't particularly pleasant.

Toronto's poor start to the 2026–27 season has put the team in some uncomfortable historical company. Through 23 games, the Maple Leafs are 8-13-2, have just 18 points, and have struggled to find consistency. They've also been dealing with a seven-game losing streak.

According to a historical comparison highlighted by Toronto Maple Leafs Central, the numbers are beginning to resemble some of the worst seasons in franchise history. That's not a comparison any Toronto fan wants to make, especially this early in the schedule. A little research confirms the numbers are accurate.

Related: Maple Leafs Have a Future Hall-of-Fame-Bound Goalie, But What’s Left?

The Maple Leafs Have Been Here Before.

The franchise's worst points percentage came in 1918–19, when the team was still known as the Toronto Arenas. That season produced a .278 points percentage. If we're looking specifically at the Maple Leafs name, the season that stands out is 1984–85. Toronto finished 20-52-8 with a .300 points percentage. Other difficult seasons include 1987–88 (.325) and 1981–82 (.350). Those were lean years for a franchise that has spent much of its history expecting to compete.

There is an important distinction, though. The 1984–85 team was rebuilding, and the expectations around that roster were considerably different. Today's Maple Leafs entered the season with a much different collection of talent and considerably higher expectations. Toronto's current .391 points percentage doesn't yet put it below those full-season marks. But we're only 23 games in, and the team’s direction is becoming a concern.

Is This Just a Bad Start or Something Worse for the Maple Leafs?

That's probably the question Maple Leafs fans are asking themselves now. A losing streak can happen to any team, but when the problems keep showing up night after night, it's reasonable to wonder whether something deeper is going on. The Maple Leafs still have plenty of hockey to play, and there's time to turn things around. But time alone won't fix whatever is happening inside this organization.

Nobody expects Toronto to repeat the miserable seasons of the past. Still, the historical comparisons remind us how quickly expectations can change when a team loses its way. Maple Leafs fans have seen some dark periods before. They were hoping those days were long gone. Right now, the team needs to give them a reason to believe those days really are behind them.

Related: Maple Leafs Fans Are Starting to Ask Bigger Questions