If Maple Leafs Fans Are Wondering About Dennis Hildeby: He's Just Fine

• 2 min read• Published November 19, 2026 at 8:16 a.m.
Featured image
Logo Crest

Many Toronto Maple Leafs fans probably haven't forgotten Dennis Hildeby. He was a young goaltender who showed enough promise in Toronto to make people wonder whether he might eventually become part of the team's long-term answer in net. Then came the surprising decision to move him to Tampa Bay in the deal that brought Nick Paul to Toronto.

So, how is Hildeby doing? Pretty well, actually. And if you're the 25-year-old goaltender, there's probably little reason to complain about where you landed.

Hildeby has settled into a backup role behind Andrei Vasilevskiy with the Tampa Bay Lightning. Through his first five starts this season, he's posted a 4-0-1 record, a 2.56 goals-against average, and an .899 save percentage. Those are encouraging numbers for a young goalie still finding his way in the NHL.

There are worse places for a developing goaltender to learn his trade than Tampa Bay. Vasilevskiy is one of the league's established elite goaltenders, and Hildeby gets to work alongside him while getting enough opportunities to show what he can do.

Related: Must the Maple Leafs Always Have Someone to Blame?

Toronto Had a Reason to Believe in Hildeby.

Maple Leafs fans saw some of that potential last season. When Anthony Stolarz and Joseph Woll were dealing with injuries and inconsistent stretches, Hildeby got extended chances in Toronto. He appeared in 20 games and finished with a 2.80 GAA and a .914 save percentage. Ironically, given what’s happened, he’d look good in a Maple Leafs sweater now.

That's a pretty respectable introduction to NHL hockey for a young goaltender. He wasn't going to solve every problem Toronto had in net, but he showed that he could handle the workload and compete at this level.

That's what makes the trade interesting now. Nick Paul has done a decent job in Toronto, and there's nothing wrong with appreciating what he brings. However, the Maple Leafs could certainly use another dependable goalie option, especially with Sergei Bobrovsky struggling this season.

Sometimes Trades Come Back to Haunt a Team. Is This One of Them?

Hildeby might not have been ready to take over a starting job, but having him available would give Toronto another option. There's also a longer-term question. Toronto once traded Tuukka Rask before he became an established NHL star. Nobody knows whether Hildeby will follow a similar path, and it's far too early to make that comparison seriously.

Still, Maple Leafs fans who were curious about how he's doing can take some encouragement from Tampa Bay's early results. Hildeby appears to be in a good place, getting NHL experience and learning from one of the best. He may have left Toronto, but his development is worth watching. The Lightning might be quite happy with what they have, and Hildeby probably isn't complaining either.

Related: If a Good Maple Leafs Effort Isn't Enough, What's Left?