3 Problems the Maple Leafs Must Solve to Find Playoff Success

The Toronto Maple Leafs are in an interesting spot heading into this season. Losing Mitch Marner isn’t just the departure of a star; it’s the end of a familiar system. Now, Craig Berube’s roster and the rest of the coaching staff have to figure out how to rebuild the team’s core rhythm while giving the youngsters meaningful roles.

It’s a delicate balancing act: you want to experiment and integrate new talent, but at the same time, you can’t risk missing the playoffs.

There’s a Case That Matthews and Nylander Should Continue Together

First things first, Auston Matthews and William Nylander should be given a chance to become full-time linemates. Why not put Nick Robertson on the other wing? Their chemistry is undeniable. Matthews’ power and finishing ability, paired with Nylander’s vision and versatility, provide the Maple Leafs with a top line that can control games. Robertson has been busting his rear lately, and he’s been noticeable on the ice.

Beyond that, Bobby McMann and Easton Cowan could be paired with John Tavares. Tavares and Cowan have shown early promise and chemistry. If McMann can come through, he can score as well. That trio could drive play in the middle of the ice while giving Matthews and Nylander space to work at the top. These are the building blocks of a lineup that could finally go deep if the pieces click.

The Maple Leafs Have Three Issues

But the Maple Leafs face three big challenges. First, they must identify forward units that actually work. Experimentation is inevitable with Marner gone, but too much shuffling risks chemistry and cohesion. Second, all this experimentation must happen in the context of the team actually making the postseason. The Atlantic Division is tight, and a slow start or inconsistent play could leave the Maple Leafs on the outside looking in.

Right now, making the postseason is a legitimate concern. And third, once in the playoffs, can this group go the distance? The team has put in the work — shoring up defense, reinforcing depth, and creating a tougher, more structured lineup — but long postseason runs require both skill and mental toughness.

Integrating Youngsters into the Maple Leafs Lineup Adds Complexity

Integrating younger players adds another layer. They need ice time to develop, but they also need to contribute without destabilizing the lineup. That’s the trick: balancing experience and youth, top-end talent and depth, all while keeping the team playoff-ready.

The good news is that the core is strong, the top lines have potential, and the Maple Leafs have the resources to make adjustments on the fly. The question is whether experimentation and the pressure of a full NHL season will allow them to solve these puzzles before the playoffs hit.

If the Maple Leafs Can Get It Right, Watch Out

If the organization can get it right, Matthews, Nylander, and Tavares could lead a team that finally lives up to its expectations. Get it wrong, and the team could be looking at another early exit. It’s a delicate line, and one worth watching closely.