Maple Leafs Freak Out, Oilers Stay Calm: Same Record, Different Reality

2 min read• Published February 4, 2026 at 12:05 p.m.
Featured image
Logo Crest

Last night was one of those games that makes you stop and think. The Toronto Maple Leafs, on the back-to-back, beat the Edmonton Oilers 5-2 on the road. That’s three straight wins out west, something nobody was really expecting. And honestly, when you actually look at the numbers, maybe it’s not that wild.

Surprise, After All These Games, the Oilers Have One Point More than the Maple Leafs.

After 57 games, the Maple Leafs have just one point less than the Oilers. One. Yet the vibe around these two teams couldn’t be more different. Toronto is a pressure cooker. Every mistake gets blown up, every game feels like life or death. Edmonton? They’re cruising. A few mistakes here and there, but nobody’s panicking. It’s business as usual.

Why the difference? A lot of it is just luck of the draw with the schedule and the divisions. The Atlantic is brutal. Every game matters, every team is dangerous, every loss feels huge. The Pacific is easier to navigate. Edmonton can pick up points without feeling like they’re fighting tooth and nail every night. And yes, the media and fan culture play a role. Toronto’s scrutiny is relentless. Edmonton’s is intense but… different.

The Two Teams Aren’t All That Far Apart, But It Seems That Way.

Still, the teams aren’t all that far apart. Talent-wise? Pretty similar. Scoring? Close. Goaltending? Not a huge gap. The difference is mostly perception. The Maple Leafs are constantly under a microscope. Edmonton isn’t—so their confidence looks calm.

It’s wild when you think about it: same record, two completely different stories. Toronto feels like it’s always on the edge. Edmonton feels like it’s just doing its thing. And the truth is, on paper, they’re almost the same.

As the Olympic break nears, it’s worth remembering that points matter, but mood matters more. And in Canadian hockey, mood can feel like everything. Being in Toronto can be exhausting—every loss feels like a headline, every win barely enough to catch your breath.

Related: How Good Can the Maple Leafs William Nylander Actually Become?