The Maple Leafs Need More Than a Goalie Who Recovers
Sergei Bobrovsky has been around long enough to know that a bad goal or two doesn’t have to ruin an entire night. The veteran goaltender has shown he can settle down, regain his focus, and keep the Toronto Maple Leafs in a game even after giving up a couple of goals he would probably like back.
That experience matters. But there is a difference between stopping the bleeding and preventing it in the first place. Right now, the Maple Leafs need to see more of the latter.
Bobrovsky Can Recover, But the Goals Are Adding Up.
Bobrovsky has shown he can find his game as a contest progresses. When he recognizes that another goal could put his team in serious trouble, he has shown he can tighten things up and give the Maple Leafs a chance to respond. That is a valuable quality in a veteran goaltender, particularly for a team still trying to find consistency in its defensive game. That’s what he did last night against the Calgary Flames.
The concern is the pattern developing around those recoveries. Eight of his nine starts have now included three or more goals against. That doesn't automatically make Bobrovsky the problem, especially when defensive breakdowns and ineffective breakouts can leave a goalie exposed. Still, a team needs its goaltender to steal a game occasionally, not just recover well enough to keep it in the game.
Related: The Growth of a Surprising Maple Leafs Cult Hero
General manager John Chayka's recent comments about Bobrovsky being a slow starter deserve consideration. He has historically needed time to get up to speed, and Chayka suggested this is actually one of the better starts Bobrovsky has had in recent memory. There is a reasonable argument for patience here.
However, patience doesn't mean ignoring the numbers. The Maple Leafs need Bobrovsky to turn those promising stretches into more complete performances, particularly when the opposing goaltender is giving his team a chance to win.
Anthony Stolarz Is Making the Decision Interesting.
Toronto has followed a goaltending schedule through a demanding stretch of October, and there is some logic in sticking with a plan rather than reacting to every result. But the schedule is about to ease, creating an opportunity to reconsider how the starts are distributed.
Anthony Stolarz has looked sharp in his last two outings. If he delivers another strong performance Thursday, the argument for giving him several consecutive starts becomes difficult to dismiss.
This isn't necessarily a referendum on Bobrovsky. Stolarz also brings an advantage with his puck-handling, which can help Toronto move the puck out of its zone and get its breakouts working more smoothly. Neither goalie can fix every problem in front of him, but small advantages can matter when a team is searching for rhythm.
There’s No Goalie Controversy in Toronto—At Least Not Yet.
The Maple Leafs don't need to turn this into a goaltending controversy. They need both goalies competing, Bobrovsky finding greater consistency, and Stolarz earning whatever opportunities come his way.
Experience counts for plenty. But performance has to count, too. The question now is whether Bobrovsky can turn his ability to recover into a stretch of games where he doesn't have to recover quite so often.