Trade Rumors Might Be Blowing Hot Air in Toronto

2 min read• Published February 5, 2026 at 6:20 p.m.
Featured image
Logo Crest

Are trade rumours getting a little bit out of hand in Toronto? Every year, around this time, the Maple Leafs turn into a giant rumour machine. Somebody whispers something, someone else tweets it, and suddenly half the fanbase is convinced the Maple Leafs are about to blow up the roster. This week has been especially wild — and honestly, some of it just feels like people entertaining themselves.

The Morgan Rielly Chatter Is Ludicrous on the Face of It.

Take the Morgan Rielly chatter. I can’t believe I even have to say this, but here we go: he’s not going anywhere. Not to the United States, not to some mystery “contender,” not even if somebody’s cousin’s dog walker heard otherwise. The guy has deep roots here. His family is Canadian through and through, he’s spoken publicly about loving Toronto, and he has a no-move clause for a reason. If you’re waiting for Rielly to pack up and head south, you might be waiting a long, long time.

The Buzz Around Bobby McMann Makes a Bit More Sense.

Then you’ve got the “buzz” around Bobby McMann. At least this one makes a sliver of sense. He’s playing well, he’s cheap, and he’s the kind of guy teams call about because they think they can pry him loose with a couple of draft picks. The only way Toronto would decide to sell would be if they asked him if he wanted to stay in Toronto, and he said no. Then, perhaps, picking up two second-round picks might work. But only if they were going to lose him for nothing.

The Maple Leafs Might Be Exploring Trades, But Rielly Won’t Be Part of Them.

But that’s where the realism ends. Outside of fringe pieces or maybe a depth shuffle, the idea that the Maple Leafs are suddenly open for business just doesn’t line up with where they are. They’re focused on clinching a playoff spot, not dismantling the roster. Trading Rielly makes zero sense. Moving McMann only makes sense if the return is too good to pass up. And most of the other names floating around feel more like content creation than actual reporting.

Honestly, this is peak Toronto: the team plays a couple of poor games, everyone gets restless, and the rumour mill fires up like someone forgot to unplug it. The trick right now is reading between the lines. Some of these stories are built on smoke, not fire.

As the Deadline Gets Closer, Pay More Attention.

As the deadline gets closer, sure, things could happen. They always do. But don’t let every headline convince you the sky is falling. The Leafs aren’t blowing up the core, and they’re not sneaking Rielly out the back door. Most of this noise is just… noise.

Let’s see what actually happens before we all talk ourselves into a panic.

Related: Maple Leafs Quick Hits: Why Are Toronto Fans Frustrated?