Firing Hiller Won’t Fix the Maple Leafs, But It Might Happen Anyway

Let’s start with the obvious: a report saying Jim Hiller could be replaced after the Columbus game isn’t confirmed. Howard Berger even said he isn’t sure about the Bruce Boudreau part. But the fact that it doesn’t sound at all unlikely tells you where the Maple Leafs are right now: eight straight losses and a blown 3-0 lead to the Kings.
So the real question isn’t “will he get fired?” It’s “would it even help?”
Related: Horrible Start? The Maple Leafs Have Been Here Before
Hiller Seems to Have Made Some Questionable Decisions.
The case for firing him mostly comes down to the overtime decision. Gavin McKenna didn’t touch the ice in a five-minute three-on-three, and Hiller said he wanted to make sure the kid is “ready.” Chris Johnston called that baffling, and it’s hard to argue. Three-on-three is made for skilled guys with open ice. When your season is sinking, you play the player who can create something. Instead, it looked like a coach trying not to lose, and that mindset rarely works in Toronto.
The case against is that the problems go way past the bench. The goaltending has been poor, the defence has been a mess, William Nylander has struggled defensively, and the special teams have fallen apart during the streak. A new coach can change lines and tone, but he can’t make an older, slower blue line faster. Boudreau himself said this summer that he didn’t see the Maple Leafs as a playoff team because of that group, which is a pretty awkward detail if he’s the guy who gets the job.
Does the Maple Leafs Front Office Think It Can Fix Things?
It gets tricky when front offices don’t always fire coaches because it’ll fix things. Sometimes it’s the only lever they can pull. The roster is expensive and hard to move, but a coach is easy to change, and with 60 games left there’s still time for a “new coach bump.” MLSE can easily afford to pay another coach to sit at home.
What to watch next: if Hiller survives Columbus, does anything actually change? The lines have barely moved, and the same ice-time questions keep coming up. If McKenna suddenly gets real minutes, that’s a sign Hiller is listening. If not, the pressure only grows.
Firing Hiller Could Put More Pressure on the Players.
The bottom line: firing Hiller would probably give the team a jolt, not solve the real issues. But when a team keeps finding new ways to lose, someone has to take the heat, and the coach usually goes first.
Related: Matthews & Nylander Set Records in Maple Leafs' 8th Straight Loss
