Maple Leafs' Fight Raises a Question About Hockey's Unwritten Code

• 2 min read• Published November 19, 2026 at 10:20 p.m.
Featured image
Logo Crest

The Toronto Maple Leafs gave their fans something to cheer about Thursday night, even if the final result against the Los Angeles Kings wasn't what they wanted. But after seven straight losses, even a point seemed worth celebrating.

What interested me was that two late-period fights brought emotion to a game. But one matchup caught our attention for another reason. Former Maple Leafs forward Scott Laughton dropped the gloves with Toronto's Teddy Blueger. Is there something unusual about fighting a player who used to be your teammate? Apparently, not as much as some fans might think.

Related: Maple Leafs Fans Are Starting to Ask Bigger Questions

The Old Teammate Rule Isn't Really a Rule.

Laughton spent part of last season with Toronto after being acquired from Philadelphia. The Maple Leafs eventually traded him to Los Angeles at the deadline. Blueger, meanwhile, joined Toronto this past summer. The two were never teammates, but Laughton certainly knows the Toronto dressing room and some of the players in it.

There's an old-school idea in hockey that players should be reluctant to fight former teammates. It sounds reasonable enough. These are guys who shared a dressing room, travelled together and went through the ups and downs of an NHL season. You might expect a little loyalty to carry over after a trade.

But that old-school idea doesn't always hold up in today's NHL. Once a player puts on another team's sweater, the relationship changes. Friendships and mutual respect may still exist, but the competitive part of the game takes over. Fighting an old teammate isn't generally considered a betrayal or a violation of some unwritten hockey rule.

Sometimes It's Simply About Who's Standing There.

That doesn't mean players never hesitate. Some would rather avoid fighting a close friend or someone they still have a strong personal relationship with. Others might look for a different opponent if they have a choice. But those are individual decisions, not some universal agreement among NHL players.

In Thursday's game, the circumstances probably mattered more than any old teammate connection. Brandon Duhaime and Corey Perry had already dropped the gloves, and the atmosphere was heating up. Almost immediately afterward, Laughton and Blueger got involved. It looked much more like the natural flow of an emotional hockey game than some carefully considered decision by either player.

Hockey’s Unwritten Code Keeps Getting Tested.

That's part of what makes hockey's unwritten code interesting. There are traditions and expectations, but they aren't always as rigid as we sometimes imagine. Players can respect one another, maintain friendships and still compete hard when they're wearing different colours.

And sometimes, when the gloves come off, the only thing that matters is who's standing across from you.

Related: Horrible Start? The Maple Leafs Have Been Here Before