The Maple Leafs May Have Lost More Than a Good Young Winger

There is always a temptation to judge a trade by the players who come back. The Maple Leafs received three NHL players in the deal that sent Matthew Knies to Columbus, including Kirill Marchenko. That's a significant return, and Toronto may have had good reasons to make the move. But Saturday's game against the Blue Jackets reminded us of something else the Maple Leafs gave up.
Knies scored twice in his first 20 games with Columbus, and his production has picked up considerably. He now has nine points in his last eight games. More importantly, he scored the tying goal against his former team late in the third period, capitalizing on a William Nylander clearing attempt that never left the Toronto zone. It was a painful moment for the Maple Leafs, but it also showed what Columbus is getting from him.
Related: Matthews & Nylander Set Records in Maple Leafs' 8th Straight Loss
Knies Was Still Becoming an Important Maple Leafs Player.
What Toronto may have lost is a player who hadn't finished developing. Knies was only 24, had already established himself as a productive NHL forward, and had become a useful part of the Maple Leafs' top six. He had 160 points in 240 games with Toronto, including a career-best 66 points last season.
Those numbers matter, but they don't tell the whole story. Knies brought size, strength, a willingness to play physically, and the ability to work around the net. He could play alongside Auston Matthews and add a different dimension to that line. Players with that combination of skills aren't always easy to replace.
There's also something to be said for a player who has grown up in an organization. Toronto drafted Knies, watched him develop, and gave him an important role. He wasn't a finished product when he arrived, and he wasn't one when he left.
The Return May Be Good, but the Cost Is Worth Watching.
Nobody knows yet how this trade will look a year or two from now. Marchenko could become a major contributor in Toronto, and the other pieces have value. But that doesn't mean the Maple Leafs won't miss Knies.
Saturday's game was a difficult way for Toronto fans to see it. Knies returned to the building where he had played his first NHL games, received a warm reception, and then scored the goal that helped send his former team to another defeat.
The bigger question isn't whether Knies had a good night. It's whether Toronto gave up a young player who could have been part of its future just when he was beginning to show how valuable he could become. That's something the Maple Leafs may have to live with for a while.
Related: Firing Hiller Won’t Fix the Maple Leafs, But It Might Happen Anyway
